Slouching towards analog tools

As you’d expect, my AI usage this year, both at work and at home, has shot through the roof. One concern that crops up here is that they start out as a useful tool but then become a crutch: they remove the need for the actual hard work of, you know, thinking. Essentially this is like outsourcing your gym workout session to a bot: the hard work of being fit requires us to exercise those muscles and you can’t really sit that part out. That exact same principle applies for the brain as well, and telling an AI to do the research and generate code (or a report) removes the need for the actual hard work to be done by the brain. Sure, smarter people can guide the AI well and get a polished report and all that, but the point is that the journey is the whole point, if you care about that sort of thing.

So, one of my ongoing goals is to also go back to some good old analog tools. Writing externalizes one’s brain and forces you to actually think about what you are trying to convey and makes you realize that that clear idea in your head is actually not so clear when you actually try to explain it.

I have a pile of notebooks filled up over the years, but I’ve not been using them so much (probably after the covid years and the resulting move to working from home). I have always loved books, and reading, and collecting stationery, so it wasn’t a hard decision to resume writing more seriously.

The first impediment was realizing just how atrocious my handwriting had become. I can barely make sense of it myself sometimes. The fix is simple and ties into the overall theme here: slow down. The mind moves fast, and the hand not so much. So writing constrains us (in a good way) as we are forced to slow down, process our thoughts, and put them to paper.

On the bright side, in a personal notebook there is no one to judge or criticize, so you are essentially free to do whatever you want. Mine has a bit of everything: doodles, bad handwriting, notes from work, highlights from books, and is totally disorganized in a way that is completely antithetical to my usual organized self. But I am somehow strangely at peace with it.

The notebook

My notebook
My current notebook.

Right now, I have settled with an unruled notebook: no dates, no lines, no sections. I tried planners and didn’t like the specific format I was forced to use.

Mine is an A5 notebook from Factor Notes (specifically it’s this one).. I’ve bought their notebooks in the past and like them, and A5 is the sweet spot for me in terms of size. The paper is 90 GSM and is fair but not great. There is some bleed-through visible in the next page and it is a bit distracting.

Zero frills otherwise: I don’t use sticky notes, bookmarks, or anything else.

The pens

A bunch of cheap but decent pens – Gel pens are good enough for pretty much everything and I’ve recently discovered that there is another kind of pen called Rollerball that is apparently completely different from Ballpoint pens. The Rollerballs I have are pretty good too. I like pens that glide easily and don’t require much pressure.

  1. Classmate Octane Gel pen
  2. Reynolds Trimax Rollerball pen
  3. Unomax Geltron Retractable Gel pen
  4. Uniball Air Rollerball pen
  5. Pilot Frixion (Erasable!) Gel pen
  6. Pentonic Gel pen
  7. Parker Fountain pen โค๏ธ
  8. Hauser XO Ball pen
  9. Faber Castell Rollerball pen โค๏ธ
  10. Brustro Mechanical pencil

These are simple, frugal but fairly good picks IMO. It turns out I like the idea of having a good pen but I don’t actually use it well when I do have one (note the only fountain pen in the list above, which is really nice, but the ink has dried up and I can’t be bothered to clean it up and fill it and maintain it)

The usage

I use Todoist heavily for task management and it has grown on me. Past attempts to move this to an analog system have failed, mainly because I need reminders on my phone. And my inability to organize sections in my notebook makes it harder for me to link and review things spread across multiple pages. So, task management is a non-starter.

The notebook is much better suited for idle thoughts, and is excellent as a scratch pad for brief throwaway notes.

I find it well suited for deeper introspection as well. For example, I periodically review my Kindle highlights and use the notebook to think a little bit more about those extracts. Todoist is still the place where I capture the thought (“write about so-and-so topic”), but the notebook is where the actual thinking happens.

Lastly, I do have a long-pending goal to improve my drawing skills. That’s another hobby that steers away from screen time and towards using one’s hands to actually create something. The notebook captures those learning sessions. For now, what I care about is reducing friction, so I’ve skipped the complications of pencils and easels and paints and what not. I just like practicing simple line art with those same pens and in that same notebook. The drawing I’ve posted above is an exercise from the excellent How to draw anything, by Mark Linley.

On Nolan’s Odyssey

I wasnโ€™t looking forward to seeing this movie but as someone who grew up on Greek mythology, I suppose I had to. As expected, I was extremely underwhelmed and couldnโ€™t wait for it to finish. Now that the dust (and hype) has settled, I came back to thinking about why I disliked it so much. Nolan is obviously a great filmmaker, and this is a massively hyped and loved movie, isnโ€™t it? Anyway, I thought about it and I think I can articulate what I think is going on:

Nolan. Doesnโ€™t. Like. The. Odyssey.

I donโ€™t have any other explanation for the bizarre choices he made all through the movie.

Why else would he take a fun, vibrant adventure about a wily, charismatic character facing off against one monstrous challenge after the other and turn it into a drab, colourless, joyless story of a soldierโ€™s PTSD from invading another land and killing its people?

Why else would he impose his own shallow morality and world-view on a story told a few thousand years back, when any student of history will tell you that the first lesson of reading historical fiction is to avoid presentism. Note for example how the movieโ€™s Odysseus simply cannot be shown to even partially enjoy his captivity under Calypso. Oh no, Calypso has to be spiking his food and causing amnesia, because our modern audience would be too confused by his behaviour.

Why else would he take powerful women (like the enigmatic and dangerous Circe, or wise Athena) and reduce them to trauma-shocked victims of male violence?

Why else would he remove all the Gods from the story, without which crucial context is missing: Poseidon vows to make Odysseusโ€™ return a misery because of what he did to the Cyclops Polyphemus; Athena however is sympathetic to his plight. Not to mention that incidents like the one with Apolloโ€™s sheep simply donโ€™t make sense without those Gods standing by ready to make good on their curse.

Why else would he constantly harp about unrelated asides (the Sea People; Zeusโ€™ Law) and try to shoehorn them into a forced โ€™twistโ€™ that he apparently is compelled to use in all his movies? Hey guess what, the Greeks were invading Troy and only a wild, desperate stretch of imagination would compare that to being guests of the Trojans. So, you could hardly say they were guilty of breaking any laws of hospitality by tricking them with a gift horse. By any definition, it was the Trojans who were guests of the Greeks and guilty of breaching Zeusโ€™s law when Paris eloped with Helen. But that wouldnโ€™t fit the narrative would it, we canโ€™t show any complexity, or the audience would get confused.

I am all for each new generation rewriting myths of old (see the Coen Brothersโ€™ O Brother, Where Art Thou? for a better interpretation of the Odyssey, or Dan Simmonsโ€™ masterful sci-fi rewrite of the Greek mythologies in Ilium), but this one just left me a bit tired.

If this one-trick pony continues to run, this is how it will all end:


NOLAN

Cast: Christopher Nolan, now in his twilight years. His muse, Mnemosyne, who may or may exist (We need to keep the audience looking for tiny clues debating about something, donโ€™t we).

Nolan in his old age, weathered and tired. Dull, grey colours.

MNEMOSYNE: โ€œYou were great once. What happened?โ€

OLD NOLAN (defiant): โ€œIโ€™m still great. Itโ€™s themโ€ฆ They donโ€™t get me anymore. I gave them legends. See how they treat me.โ€

Flashback to Nolan in his youth, filming Memento. Colours are vibrant. We see Nolan enthusiastically creating meta-narratives, looping stories, and not talking down to his audience.

MNEMOSYNE (voice over): โ€œWhere is that Nolan now?โ€

OLD NOLAN (defiant): โ€œI had my fill with those stories. What captivates me more is stories of powerful characters wracked by guilt. The guilt of Oppenheimer. The guilt of Odysseus.โ€

MNEMOSYNE: โ€œGuilt? Odysseus had no guilt. He had regret. He cried for the years he lost. He accepted his fate and waged a war he could not escape from, and paid for it with an arduous journey back.โ€

OLD NOLAN (doubtful): โ€œBut the guilt… I saw it…โ€

Cut to close up of Nolanโ€™s withered face. His famous twist is about to come.

MNEMOSYNE: โ€œThe guilt was in you.โ€

END

20 years of blogging

For the past few years, I have been using a static site to manage my book and game lists, tech notes and so on. It was running on mkdocs for most of that time, but I recently vibe-coded a complete (and impressively seamless) switch to Hugo. I had some fun adding easter eggs and other features to it. Since then, I’ve also tried to spend more time writing, both in my analog journal and in that site.

Today I noticed that my very first post in this blog was in November 2006, twenty long years back! I was struck by a bit of nostalgia. I also noticed that the one thing missing in my static site (for now still visible at https://arunsrin-mkdocs.pages.dev/) is a lack of images.

So, here we go again. I have always flip-flopped between that site and this blog every few years. This is probably just the latest iteration. But, let’s see if it lasts longer than earlier attempts.

Here’s a pic from one of the few games I finished this year, Resonance: A Plague Tale Legacy.

Books Read in May

I was only able to read 2 books this month, so I’m not very happy. Some inconsistent timings at work changed my routine a bit so my reading took a hit.

The Battles of Tolkien, by David Day

A book to be held. With lovely illustrations and binding, it is a joy to read. Quite short though, and I was expecting a bit more depth in many of the sections.

How the World Works, by Noam Chomsky

A collection of 4 books, collecting interviews given by Chomsky in a variety of topics. An excellent summary of his worldview.